The latest issue of Auto Bild warns drivers not to buy a pig in a poke. Test results rather than blind luck should guide tyre purchases. To help in this area the motoring publication has now shared the outcome of its 2020 winter tyre test. This evaluation of size 245/45 R18 tyres for executive cars (Auto Bild used a BMW 5 Series for testing) compares the 20 best performers from an initial field of 51 tyre brands subjected to wet and snow braking tests. Six of the brands received Auto Bild’s top ‘exemplary’ rating.
Exemplary tyres
Test winner: Michelin Pilot Alpin 5
+ Snow, wet & dry performance, short braking distances, mileage & economy
– High purchase price
Bridgestone Blizzak LM 005
+ All round winter performance, wet & dry handling, comfort, rolling resistance
– Mileage just average
Goodyear UltraGrip Performance+
+ Top performance on snowy & dry surfaces, safe driving characteristics on wet surfaces, good aquaplaning safety reserves
– Comfort just average
BFGoodrich g-Force Winter 2
+ Good value & mileage, convincing on snow, good aquaplaning properties
– Rolling resistance
Kleber Krisalp HP 3
+ Affordable brand-name tyre with high levels of performance, balanced handling in all conditions, mileage
– Rolling resistance
Hankook Winter i*cept evo3
+ New winter tyre with sporty performance on wet & dry surfaces, good on snow, short braking distances in the wet & on snow
– Rolling resistance
A ‘good’ rating for 9 tyres
Continental WinterContact TS 850P
+ Wet specialist with sporty dynamic handling in all conditions, precise steering behaviour, very good mileage
– Dry braking distances, high purchase price
Dunlop Winter Sport 5
+ Balanced winter tyre with convincing performance on snow, high aquaplaning safety reserves, comfort
– Wet braking distances, purchase price
Apollo Aspire XP Winter
+ Good traction & short braking distances on snow, good aquaplaning safety, dynamic handling in dry conditions
– Lateral control on snow, wet braking distances
Semperit Speed Grip 3
+ Short braking distances & dynamic driving behaviour in wet conditions, mileage & economy
– Narrow aquaplaning safety reserves
Fulda Kristall Control HP2
+ Convincing on snow, good aquaplaning safety reserves, comfort, mileage
– Extended wet braking distances, understeer in the wet & dry
Vredestein Wintrac Pro
+ Balanced performance in all conditions, short braking distances on snow, dynamic wet handling
– Rolling resistance, efficiency just average
Giti GitiWinter W1
+ Short braking distances & good traction on snow, dynamic wet handling behaviour, mileage, purchase price
– Wet braking distances, average aquaplaning characteristics
Uniroyal MS plus 77
+ Strong performance on snow, good aquaplaning safety reserves, ride comfort
– Wet grip, mileage
Barum Polaris 5
+ Balanced good driving behaviour on dry & snowy surfaces, good aquaplaning safety reserves
– Wet braking distances, mileage, rolling resistance
4 tyres rated ‘satisfactory’
Laufen I Fit +
+ Good on snow with stable lateral control & short braking distances, mileage
– Wet grip, wet & dry understeer
Nokian WR A4
+ Balanced safety in dry conditions, low ride noise, low rolling resistance
– Understeer on snow, average aquaplaning safety
General Altimax Winter 3
+ Affordable value, good snow performance, quiet ride noise
– Understeer in wet & dry conditions, aquaplaning safety
Pirelli Winter Sottozero 3
+ Convincing handling on snow & in dry conditions, rolling resistance
– Wet grip, mileage, price
The new Pirelli P Zero Winter was introduced too late to be included in Auto Bild’s testing; the latest-generation tyre offers improved performance on snow & ice as well as better wet grip
Conditionally recommended
Cooper WeatherMaster SA2
+ Aquaplaning safety reserves, noise, price
– Grip on snow & ice, understeer in dry conditions, mileage
A further 31 of the tested tyre brands failed to make the cut, with 20 brands disqualified due to their lengthy braking distances in the wet. Auto Bild says these tyres are not worth the price paid for them.
